In addition to eating a lot of food, we also read about it extensively. There are always those restaurants that get praised by just about every blogger and food critic in the area. Restaurant Eve, Komi, Corduroy. Okay, these are great places, we get it. But what we don’t get is why a place that is packed every night and serves up such fantastic Italian food is largely ignored by the local food media: Trattoria da Franco in Old Town. Others may disagree, but Trattoria is very nearly the equal of A La Lucia, another Alexandria neighborhood Italian that, though only a recent arrival, has already been assigned to double duty on both the Washingtonian's 100 Best Bargains and 100 Very Best lists of Washington area restaurants.
One of the things that surprises me about Trattoria’s virtual absence from the food-obsessed community is that its façade is so distinctive; a food critic should have been inspired to enter just on looks alone. The building is clearly an old colonial vestige, but it’s been done all up Italian villa-style and adorned with loads of ivy and other décor. The romantic outdoor seating and chalkboard specials menu gives diners a first glimpse of what is in store—even more romantic ambiance that is a slightly more elegant and European version of the 1950s neighborhood red sauce Italian. Inside a cozy pair of dining rooms feature low lighting and fabulous wall hangings that include vintage photos of Italy and Asian opera brochures. And we are always met with an extremely friendly staff (who recognized us, even predicted our appetizer after a good half-year of absentia) and live music (this time it was a piano player and a woman singing 1950s standards) including a regular Sunday opera night.
During our visit the other night, as previously mentioned, one of the waiters correctly guessed that we’d be ordering an appetizer of zucchini fritte (zucchini strips very lightly fried, served with a savory marinara sauce). This is hands-down one of our favorite Italian appetizers, and Trattoria does a fantastic job. The strips are fleshy and soft, and, frankly, just the tart essence from a squeeze or two of the lemon provided is all that they require; the marinara sauce actually takes away from the light, buttery fried coating and texture of the zucchini. However, it should be known that the marinara is outstanding in its own right.
We also tried the spinach and mushroom salad, which has become an AC and AK favorite at Italian joints, particularly Café Monti. It's so simple—raw spinach, raw mushrooms, a lemon vinaigrette with a touch of egg— but allows for a healthy starter with a surprising amount of depth, making you ready to dive into the entrees, both of which blew away our lofty expectations.
The penne amatraciana came perfectly al dente (the pasta is homemade), smothered in a sweet tomato sauce, a liberal addition of diced onion, and its smokiness the result of the wonderful pancetta (Italian bacon). This is the kind of pasta dish, that, if I could afford a weekly purchase of pancetta, I would make instead of my standard marinara. And though amatraciana sauce is usually spicy, not sweet, it was a perfect counterpoint to the salty pork.
Our other entrée was a house special: butternut squash ravioli with a pink sauce. Usually those pink sauces are deceiving. You think, “This won’t be heavy, it’s pink!” And then you’re wrong; it coagulates into a brick of fat sitting in your stomach. But this dish was refreshingly light, though I have no illusions about the amount of butterfat involved. The six large homemade ravioli were showstoppers. Each bite was a combination of al dente pasta, squash puree, and an explosion of some kind of fabulous spice—cinnamon, allspice, I have no idea. But it was key to taking this dish from great to excellent.
The Bread
Bread seems to be the main thing that Italian restaurants use to set themselves apart because all of our favorite places offer a bread that has its own genius to it. For us, bread is not just a prelude to a meal, but also a vehicle for scooping and sopping. Trattoria opts for a soft, chewy loaf with a very modest crust accompanied by an olive oil dipping sauce mixed with a bit of pesto, resulting in a cloudy lime-green mixture bursting with flavor.
Old Favorites
During previous visits, we identified a couple of standbys. One is the outstanding eggplant melanzane. See here for details. Also, I became obsessed for a while about the saturated-fat fest that is carbonara sauce (butter, cream, cheese, eggs, pancetta). It started when I saw Mario Batali make it on Martha Stewart’s cooking show (pre-prison). He did it the traditional way, whereby you crack a raw egg on the top, right before sticking your fork in. I believe he said this is basically the Italian eggs and ham and that it is frequently eaten for breakfast. So for several weeks straight I would order the linguine carbonara at Trattoria. Though the egg is incorporated in the sauce behind the scenes, this is still one of the most decadent, fattening, and exciting of Italian pasta dishes for me. Each twirl of pasta is glistening with butter and sheathed in the creamy sauce. The pancetta, for me, just adds needed salt and texture, and the carbonara (referring to the liberal sprinkling of pepper) really brings it on home, as I’m crazy about freshly cracked pepper and suffer from chronic overuse of it at home.
Please visit Trattoria da Franco at:
305 South Washington Street
Alexandria, Virginia
(703) 548-9338
—AK